Cleveland Indians' 2007 season built with character and conviction

Cleveland Indians' 2007 season built with character and conviction
Sunday, December 23, 2007Paul HoynesPlain Dealer Reporter
It's hard to be an idealist in Major League Baseball. To always look at the bright side of a game that bears so many scars, might call into question one's view of reality.

Mark Shapiro, Indians general manager, chooses to do so anyway. He knows all too well that this is not a perfect business plied by knights in shining armor. Yet he has always tried to build teams that stress character and chemistry. Some of that has been induced by one of the lowest payrolls in the game, but rarely are convictions and principles sidestepped to bow before the persistent drumbeat of victory.

On Sept. 23, Shapiro saw his convictions come to life when the Indians beat Oakland, 6-2, at Jacobs Field to clinch the AL Central Division. Shapiro has worked for the Indians since 1992, but this was his first division championship as a general manager.

In the locker-room celebration after the game, Shapiro, an AL Central Division championship baseball cap pulled tightly on his head to break the ever-flowing waterfall of champagne and beer, gazed at pockets of gyrating players and felt good about every one of them.

Steady Jake Westbrook pitched seven innings for the victory. Young lefty Rafael Perez, representing a productive farm system that saved the season, relieved and recorded two quick outs before Rafael Betancourt, perhaps the best set-up man in the league last season, pitched the final 1 1/3 innings for the save.

Grady Sizemore, a rock Shapiro feels will support this team for seasons to come, had hits in his first four at-bats and reached base five straight times. Casey Blake, the model for manager Eric Wedge's grind-it-out ballplayer, hit a two-run double to start the decisive four-run fourth inning.

Shapiro had a memory for every celebrating player. Maybe it was about the scout who recommended C.C. Sabathia as a high school senior or how Fausto Carmona transformed himself from a failed closer to one of the best starters in the game.

It took nearly six hard years of work to see the Indians' locker room at Jacobs Field in such delirious disarray that day. Shapiro knew that it would never be this good, this pure, again. He drank it in like a thirsty man.

The Indians won seven division titles and reached two World Series from 1995 through 2001. Those teams were so talented, and often so arrogant in displaying that talent, that the sense of accomplishment from those in the organization was dulled.

Compromises were made. Heads were turned. Confrontations avoided -- all in the name of trying to win a world championship that never came.

When Shapiro became general manager in November 2001, the team was old and the farm system played out. He knew he'd have to start over, it was just a matter of when. But when the time came to win, Shapiro wanted to do it differently than before.

On Sept. 23, it happened. The Indians kept winning, finishing at 96-66 and tying Boston for the best record in baseball.

They upset the Yankees in the AL Division Series in four games. They took a 3-1 lead against Boston in the AL Championship Series, only to lose three straight. The morning of Game 7 of the ALCS, the San Francisco Chronicle reported Tribe starter Paul Byrd purchased $25,000 of human growth hormone and syringes from 2002-05.

Reality has a way of bruising idealists, but Sept. 23 was perfect.

To reach this Plain Dealer reporter:

phoynes@plaind.com, 216-999-5158